One tidbit I found out while putting this doc together is that, in addition to the website, there's a
My First Time stage play that apparently had a pretty successful off-Broadway run in 2007! It seems to consist of actors performing stories that were submitted to the website- they must have really had to do some digging to find non-insane stories to adapt, because no matter where in the archives I searched the stories seemed to be equally porn-y.
The stories in this episode could make a solid sequel script. It could even be a musical, since we've got a lovely song about a fat boot touching some guy's pinacolada!