Insider info:
On the very last reading on this one, Jimmyfranks is given a Lemon's Dillemma, and he opts for a story that devolves into a furry getting a wedgie from another furry in a hotel restroom.
That was actually a retake. Originally Jimmyfranks chose the Final Fantasy piece and I listened to it while skimming the piece he didn't pick, then at one point informed him that he should back up and choose again.
It's the only time the Dillemma has ended that way, but I was just reminded of that, listing to this ep and hearing Boots go "Eh, I bet the other one was better."