Oh boy, here we go. In no particular order...
The whole of the JustRage episode. Portaxx's mock angry noises get me every time. Rrrgrrbrrbrrbrrr! Also HOO-RAH-FUCKIN'-YAY. And Acier banging his bourbon bottle on the counter for emphasis.
"Was the cock carousel worth it?"
The whole of the creepypasta episode. "I'm really good at typing with my nose!"
One of my friends who listens to the podcast with me absolutely loves Bunnybread's voice repertoire. He heard Bunnybread bouncing between voices in the 100th and has been asking me for more ever since. XP
The none-foot gaint and the supper killer.
Jack Chick losing it over "JUSTIN BUTTFUCK IS COMING TO MY SCHOOL! DZRZRTD ALL THE METALHEADS ARE GONNA KILL HIM."
Acier's love spell gone wrong. That whole episode really, since I can't forget THE KILLING SPELLLLLLLLL.
Patrick82 and the rest of the audiophiles. Patrick82 has become something of a meme in my group of friends as the archetypal creepy serial killer guy.
The readings of unrelated fanfiction snippets from "This Is What You Want? This Is What You Get!"
Connie Marshall, Queen of Tinfoil Hats. Also the running joke of Bunnybread's marriage to her.
Any time Portaxx comments on wanting to hug things like pterodactyls, since I usually feel the same way. XP
Any PUA/men's rights episode, since I consider those public safety announcements. You hear anything that reminds you of these guys, WALK AWAY ASAP.
Cheeeeeevoooooooos!
F Plus Sings. Just in general. I've occasionally found myself with bits from it stuck in my head. "Where the heck is that 'society's the blind teacher' song from? .... OH."
Any time a reader loses it laughing and either can't finish their sentence or comments on needing to mute their microphone through giggles.
"I've certainly never pissed in a Mountain Dew bottle. I don't think it's possible!" "I've never peed in a slurpee cup from a 7-11."
"These are all things that have presumably happened to someone other than us." -shroom experiences
Kumquatting.
The dirty talk Mad Lib from one of the F Plus Live shows.
Almost any time a reader goes "Yaaaaaaay!"
Jimmyfranks winning bingo in one sentence.
The hexadecimal joke race.
"And timing."