I don't think I'm alone in the Christian Domestic Discipline vibes I got from these guys. Not just in their shared language of "let's take things back to an earlier time, when things were happier" but in their intense, focused insistence that this isn't weird, and people who think it's weird are wrong, and if you just tried it you'd understand.
Some other people have mentioned just how creepy it made them feel, and it's a weird contrast to something like the F-list episode, which by every objective standard is so much more viscerally gross. It's not just the absurdity, it's that no one on that site was trying to argue that it was entirely normal and not weird at all that they're into Demonic Cum. That's what makes this episode and the CDD one so creepy and weird: the constant insistence that no, it's not weird, it's not a sex thing, this is what people really need in order to feel fulfilled.